The Good Contractors List vs. Directorii: Which Platform Should You Choose for Your Next Home Project?
In today’s home improvement landscape, finding a reliable contractor can feel like a gamble. Horror stories of shoddy work, abandoned jobs, and scams are all too common. That’s where vetted contractor platforms come in—services that pre-screen professionals and often back their work with financial guarantees to give homeowners peace of mind.
Two standout options are The Good Contractors List (TGCL) and Directorii. Both aim to connect homeowners with trusted contractors, but they differ in history, scope, features, and focus. The Good Contractors List, founded in 2011, originated the “Guarantee Space” in the contractor referral industry—pioneering the concept of backing vetted contractors with a substantial financial guarantee when it was unheard of. This mature model has allowed TGCL to build a robust network over more than a decade.
Directorii, a newer national platform with roots in roofing, has expanded quickly and emphasizes high-value protection. But for many homeowners, especially those seeking variety in services, TGCL’s longevity translates to more options.
Let’s break down the key differences to help you decide which is better suited for your needs.
Key Differences: The Good Contractors List vs. Directorii
Feature | The Good Contractors List (TGCL) | Directorii |
Founded / History | Founded in 2011; originated the “Guarantee Space” by being the first to offer substantial financial backing on vetted contractors | Newer platform, originally focused on roofing before expanding nationally |
Geographic Coverage | Nationwide (US) HQ in Dallas-Fort Worth | Nationwide (US and Canada) |
Workmanship Guarantee | Up to $350,000 for Elite contractors (addtl fee applies for larger coverage); standard $25,000 guarantee covers both deposit protection and the job/workmanship itself | Basic $30,000 guarantee covers only theft of deposit/fraud/bankruptcy; up to $250,000 full coverage (workmanship, materials, code issues) available as an upgrade for a percentage of the job |
Number of Home Service Trades | More trades available due to the maturity of their model—extensive categories built over 14+ years, offering homeowners broader options for various projects | Fewer publicly listed trades; started with roofing and expanded to select categories like remodeling, plumbing, siding, and electrical |
Cost to Contractors | Fixed, predictable operational expense every month—no percentage fees; full standard $25,000 guarantee (covering deposit and job) included at no additional cost | $49/month membership; additional percentage fee (1-5% of project amount) charged to provide the up to $250,000 guarantee |
Vetting Process | Rigorous (often times in-person) interviews, contractors must be in business 3 years, pass business & criminal background checks, ongoing monitoring | Strict criteria including 4.5+ star Google reviews, financial vetting, and code of ethics |
Cost to Homeowners | Completely free; one-time registration activates lifetime guarantee coverage | Free to use; concierge service for unmatched needs |
Additional Features | Mediation services, on-site inspections for disputes, strong emphasis on local trust and accountability | App for easy access, scam alerts, cost guides, real payout examples for claims |
Best For | Homeowners throughout the U.S. wanting maximum trade variety, predictable contractor guarantees , and pioneering protection | Homeowners needing national reach, especially for roofing or high-value projects |
Ultimately, both platforms prioritize trust and quality over volume, rejecting pay-to-play models common on sites like Angi or Thumbtack. The Good Contractors List stands out for its pioneering role in guarantees since 2011, its mature ecosystem with more home service trades, and its contractor-friendly fixed monthly pricing that includes comprehensive standard coverage without job-based percentages—making it ideal if variety, longevity, and cost predictability matter most to you.
Directorii shines for broad geographic access, modern tools, and higher potential guarantees (with the added fee on standard job coverage). Whichever you choose, registering is free and quick for homeowners—start by visiting their sites to search for contractors in your area. Your next home project deserves the best protection possible!
*all information pulled from online resources and is deemed as accurate as possible at the time this blog was published
Join Thousands of Homeowners Who Are
Protected by Our $25,000 Guarantee
READY TO START YOUR PROJECT WITH CONFIDENCE?
Register now and immediately be covered by our exclusive guarantee!
Home improvement projects can be stressful, but finding a trustworthy contractor shouldn’t be.
When you register your project with The Good Contractors List, you get:
- Pre-Screened, Trusted Contractors – Every contractor is carefully vetted for quality and integrity.
- Our $25,000 Guarantee – If anything goes wrong, we stand behind the work—at no cost to you.
- Peace of Mind – Know your home and investment are in safe, reliable hands.
